The Michigan Catastrophic Claims Association (MCCA) plays a significant role in the administration of catastrophic No-Fault claims, yet its involvement can have a substantial impact on injured individuals and their families. This article examines the MCCA’s role under Michigan’s No-Fault Act, its influence over claims involving catastrophic injuries, and the practical effects of its decisions on accident victims and family caregivers.
What Is the MCCA?
The Michigan Catastrophic Claims Association (“MCCA”) is an unincorporated association whose purpose is to provide no-fault insurers with indemnification for injury claims that exceed a certain threshold. In the worst automobile accidents, the insured might be left severely injured, permanently disabled, and require ongoing care for the remainder their life. The state legislature created the MCCA in response to concerns that Michigan’s no-fault law provision for unlimited no-fault benefits placed too great a burden on insurers, particularly small insurers, in the event of a catastrophic injury claim. Michigan drivers fund the MCCA through “MCCA Assessments” that are charged for every insured vehicle in the state.
In US Fidelity & Guaranty Co. v. Mich Catastrophic Claims Ass’n, 484 Mich 1 (2009), our Supreme Court explained that while the MCCA is responsible to indemnify the insurer, the duty of assessing and adjusting claims remains the responsibility of the insurance company. That is, determining the “reasonableness” of the claim, including the reasonable necessity of the product, service, or accommodation itself as well as the “reasonable charge” the insurer is responsible to pay, is the responsibility of the insurance company. In that same decision, however, the Supreme Court also stated that the MCCA “can exercise control over the settlement process.”
In recent years, the MCCA has blurred the lines between “exercising control over the settlement process” and determining “reasonableness” of a claimed benefit. In claims involving the catastrophically injured, the MCCA frequently determines which claims are compensable and the appropriate rate of compensation for the claim. Unfortunately, the MCCA’s determinations often are arbitrary and lack any basis in reality.
The Practical Effects of the MCCA’s Takeover of Claims Determinations: The Case of In-Home Care
The MCCA’s actions feature prominently in claims for family member in-home care. Sometimes a family member of a catastrophically injured car crash survivor gives up their own family or career aspirations to provide their loved one with necessary and needed care. The MCCA’s “approved rate” for this service and personal sacrifice often is less than an entry-level employee at McDonald’s and sometimes equal to the state’s minimum wage. The MCCA does not seem to care that the alternative is for the care to be provided by a commercial provider with a much higher billed rate. Perhaps this is because it knows that after the family member/service provider has foregone opportunities for outside employment and career advancement while their time is spent providing care, it is very difficult to leave their severely disabled loved one with strangers while attempting to restart a professional career.
Not to take anything away from hardworking McDonald’s employees, but it can’t seriously be argued that assisting an individual with basic activities of daily living, including bowel movements, doesn’t warrant a lot more than minimum wage. Our legislature does not seem to be in any hurry to fix this problem with the no-fault system. Regrettably, the only answer for these individuals is the court system and trusting eight members of the public, a civil jury, to confirm they have a right to a fair wage.
We need new legislation to fix a broken system that devalues and takes advantage of a family member’s sacrifice on behalf of a catastrophically injured auto accident victim. At this website, Miller, Tischler & Vislosky will keep you updated on legislative developments in these areas. In the meantime, we encourage you, your family members and friends to contact your state representatives and speak out in support of no-fault reforms that work on behalf of auto accident victims rather than insurance companies.
Key Takeaways
- • The Michigan Catastrophic Claims Association (MCCA) reimburses insurers for catastrophic No-Fault claims that exceed a statutory threshold.
- • Although insurers remain responsible for adjusting claims, the MCCA may exercise significant influence over the settlement process.
- • The MCCA’s decisions can have a substantial impact on catastrophically injured accident victims and family members who provide in-home care.
- • Legislative reform is needed to better protect catastrophically injured accident victims and family caregivers under Michigan’s No-Fault system.
