Under Michigan’s No-Fault Act, MCL 500.3145, the one-year-back rule generally prevents a claimant from recovering personal protection insurance (PIP) benefits for losses incurred more than one year before a lawsuit is filed. For years, that rule was one of the most reliable defenses in the no-fault playbook. If a bill was more than a year old when the complaint was filed, it was usually barred.
But in 2019, the Legislature amended MCL 500.3145 to add a statutory tolling provision. Under subsection (3), the applicable one-year period is tolled “from the date of a specific claim for payment of the benefits until the date the insurer formally denies the claim.” The provision also requires the claimant to pursue the claim with reasonable diligence.
In practical terms, the amendment may protect qualifying claims from the one-year-back rule if an insurer has not formally denied them. While the 2019 amendment may potentially protect claims that are more than one year old, it is always best practice to file suit no later than the 1-year point if possible.
Spine Specialists v MemberSelect: Does the Tolling Rule Apply Retroactively?
The threshold issue is whether a claim can use the new tolling rule at all. The Michigan Supreme Court answered that in April 2025, in Spine Specialists of Michigan, PC v MemberSelect Ins Co, ___ Mich ___; ___ NW3d ___ (2025) (Docket No. 165445).
A medical provider treated a patient who had been injured in a 2017 car accident. The provider filed suit on September 21, 2020, to pursue bills incurred more than a year earlier, in April and May 2019. Its argument was simple: the new tolling rule applies, MemberSelect never formally denied the claims, so the clock never ran.
The Court rejected that argument. Writing for the majority, Chief Justice Clement explained that a claim for medical expenses accrues when the treatment is provided. These claims accrued before the amendment took effect on June 11, 2019, so applying the new tolling rule to them would make it retroactive, and the Legislature never said it should be. The Court also found it would be unfair to hold insurers to a formal-denial standard that didn’t exist when they handled those bills.
The result: For charges incurred before June 11, 2019, the one-year-back rule applies as strictly as ever, no matter how the insurer responded to the claim for payment.
Encompass v Citizens: Did the Insurer Formally Deny the Claim?
For charges incurred on or after June 11, 2019, the key question is often whether, and when, the insurer formally denied the claim. The statute doesn’t define “formal denial,” but the Court of Appeals took it up in Encompass Healthcare, PLLC v Citizens Ins Co, 344 Mich App 248 (2022).
In Encompass, the insurer argued that its Explanation of Review (EOR) notices, which showed partial payments on the provider’s charges, were formal denials that started the one-year clock. The trial court agreed, but the Court of Appeals reversed. Before the Supreme Court abolished tolling in Devillers v Auto Club Ins Ass’n (2005), Michigan courts had spent decades defining what a formal denial looks like, and the 2019 amendment brought that language back. Drawing on cases such as Mousa v Citizens Ins Co, 185 Mich App 293; 460 NW2d 310 (1990), McNeel v Farm Bureau Gen Ins Co of Mich, 289 Mich App 76; 795 NW2d 205 (2010), and Smitham v State Farm Fire & Cas Co, 297 Mich App 537; 824 NW2d 601 (2012), the Court held that a formal denial must be “explicit and unequivocal” and must “impress upon the insured the need to pursue further relief in court.” In other words, the insurer has to say clearly that it is denying all liability beyond what it has already paid. The Court also explained why that matters: a direct denial puts the claimant on notice that the clock is ticking, while relying on inferred denials invites the very disputes the no-fault act is meant to avoid.
The court held that Citizens’ EORs didn’t meet that standard. The EORs explained why charges were reduced or only partly paid, but they never said the insurer was refusing to pay anything more. In fact, Citizens’ own practices allowed charges to be reconsidered after an EOR went out. The EORs did include a general disclaimer, but the Court treated it as boilerplate, not a clear denial. Because Citizens never formally denied the claims, the Court held that the one-year clock stayed paused until the provider filed suit.
Conclusion: Issues to Consider When Reviewing the One-Year-Back Defense
Encompass and Spine Specialists establish two separate questions that should be considered when evaluating a potential one-year-back defense.
First, does the amended tolling provision apply? Counsel should identify when the underlying PIP claim accrued and determine whether the claim falls within the scope of MCL 500.3145(3). Under Spine Specialists, the provision does not apply retroactively to claims that began accruing before June 11, 2019. The date the lawsuit was filed, standing alone, is not enough.
Second, if the tolling provision applies, did the insurer formally deny the specific claim? Under Encompass, an EOR or partial payment does not necessarily constitute a formal denial. A reduction notice that leaves open the possibility of further review may not be sufficient. The insurer’s communication must clearly and unequivocally convey finality.
For bills accruing before June 11, 2019, the one-year-back rule is as strict as ever. For expenses incurred after that date, the fight is over whether, and when, the insurer clearly said no. While the 2019 amendment may potentially protect claims that are more than one year old, we reiterate that it is always best practice to file suit no later than the 1-year point if possible.
